New Zealand licensing authorities have rejected a patched biker’s application to work as a security guard, citing concerns that his loyalty to the motorcycle club could interfere with his professional responsibilities.
NEW ZEALAND — A member of the Greazy Dogs Motorcycle Club has been refused permission to work in the private security industry after authorities determined that his ongoing gang membership raised concerns about his suitability for the role.
William Rutene applied for a certificate of approval to become a security guard but was unsuccessful following objections from New Zealand Police.
The Private Security Personnel Licensing Authority rejected his application in a decision dated October 29.
Although Rutene has no criminal convictions and successfully completed the required security training, the authority concluded that his continued membership in the Greazy Dogs presented an unacceptable risk.
Police Raise Concerns Over Motorcycle Club Membership
During the licensing proceedings, police argued that the Greazy Dogs Motorcycle Club is an outlaw motorcycle organization formally classified as a gang under Schedule 2 of New Zealand’s Gangs Act 2024.
Authorities also raised concerns about the club’s use of the “1%” symbol, which police described as representing a rejection of conventional laws and adherence to an independent motorcycle club code.
Rutene acknowledged that he became a fully patched Greazy Dogs member in 2022 and continues to belong to the organization.
He also confirmed having several tattoos associated with the club.
These include the club’s patch tattooed across his back, the letters “GDMC” on his leg and the recognizable 1% symbol.
However, Rutene disputed the suggestion that his motorcycle club involvement indicated criminal behaviour.
He maintained that the Greazy Dogs was simply a motorcycle club and denied having any connection to criminal activity.
Clean Criminal Record Not Enough to Secure Approval
The application was reviewed by licensing authority member P A McConnell, who considered Rutene’s personal background, training and character references.
McConnell acknowledged several factors in Rutene’s favour.
The applicant had no previous criminal convictions, had completed the necessary qualifications for security work and supplied positive references.
Those supporting his application described him as a devoted family man, a reliable friend and a valued member of his community.
The authority also accepted that no direct evidence had been presented connecting Rutene personally to criminal offending.
Despite those considerations, McConnell remained concerned about the obligations and expectations associated with active membership in a patched motorcycle gang.
The decision questioned whether Rutene could realistically remain unaware of, or entirely separate from, criminal activities involving other members of the organization.
Authority Questions Where His Loyalty Would Lie
A central issue in the ruling was whether Rutene could be trusted to place his legal obligations and responsibilities to an employer ahead of his loyalty to the Greazy Dogs.
McConnell concluded that active patched membership created a significant conflict.
The authority considered it more likely than not that Rutene could face pressure to assist fellow gang members or ignore criminal conduct while performing security duties.
The decision referred to previous cases involving patched gang members employed in security positions.
Those cases had raised concerns about security personnel being expected to assist criminal organizations through activities such as:
- Facilitating drug distribution at licensed venues
- Providing unauthorized access codes to secured buildings
- Informing gang leaders about the presence of rival motorcycle club members
- Refusing to cooperate with police investigations
These examples came from earlier proceedings and were not findings that Rutene had personally engaged in such activities.
Nevertheless, McConnell considered them relevant when assessing the potential risks associated with granting his application.
Recent Greazy Dogs Investigations Considered
The licensing authority also examined recent police investigations involving members of the Greazy Dogs Motorcycle Club.
One investigation highlighted in the decision was Operation Kingtide, conducted in 2025.
During that operation, police charged 20 Greazy Dogs members with offences involving drugs and firearms.
Investigators alleged that the motorcycle club had established significant control over methamphetamine distribution in New Zealand’s Bay of Plenty region.
The investigation also resulted in the restraint of assets valued at more than $1.5 million.
Another incident considered by the authority occurred in April 2026.
Five Greazy Dogs members faced criminal charges, including rioting and assault, following a violent confrontation with members of the Mongols Motorcycle Club.
The clash reportedly took place outside a McDonald’s restaurant in Mount Maunganui, in the Bay of Plenty.
According to the allegations, the dispute involved motorcycle club insignia being worn in an area claimed as territory by another organization.
The authority considered these incidents when evaluating the broader activities and reputation of the Greazy Dogs.
Neither investigation established that Rutene personally participated in the alleged offences.
Security Guard Application Formally Rejected
After reviewing the evidence and submissions, McConnell determined that Rutene did not satisfy the character and background requirements for employment in the private security industry.
The application was declined under section 53(3) of the Private Security Personnel and Private Investigators Act 2010.
The decision emphasized that the refusal was based on concerns arising from Rutene’s active patched membership and the potential conflict between club loyalty and professional security obligations.
While recognizing his lack of criminal convictions and positive personal references, the authority concluded that those factors did not sufficiently address the identified risks.
As a result, Rutene was denied the certificate of approval required to work as a security guard.