Skip to content
BREAKING NEWS
Biker News

(CAN) Outlaws Motorcycle Club Member and Wife Stand Trial Over Sarnia Remembrance Day Confrontation

Court hears conflicting accounts of a 2024 incident involving a black memorial wreath, motorcycle club members and police arrests during a ceremony honouring Canadian veterans.

SARNIA, ONTARIO — A controversial confrontation between police and members of the Outlaws Motorcycle Club at a Remembrance Day ceremony in Sarnia is now being examined in court, nearly two years after the incident resulted in two arrests.

Arthur Shura, an alleged member of the Outlaws Motorcycle Club, and his wife, Karen Pelkie, are standing trial over events that unfolded at Veterans Park on November 11, 2024.

The incident occurred during the Royal Canadian Legion Branch 62’s annual Remembrance Day service, when several people wearing motorcycle club vests attempted to place a black wreath at the cenotaph.

What began as an attempt to participate in the wreath-laying ceremony escalated into a confrontation with police after the group was told to leave the procession.

The trial, being heard by Justice Krista Lynn Leszczynski without a jury, began in late October and is scheduled to continue in November.

Remembrance Day Wreath Sparks Dispute

According to Sarnia police, several individuals wearing outlaw motorcycle club clothing joined the wreath-laying procession despite not being part of the official ceremony.

The group carried a black wreath featuring colours associated with the motorcycle club.

Police stated that Legion representatives did not want the group participating in the formal procession and requested that officers remove them.

Authorities alleged that members of the group refused to leave and became disruptive, using loud and offensive language during the confrontation.

The disturbance reportedly continued as police escorted individuals away from the cenotaph toward a nearby roadway.

Two people were ultimately arrested.

Shura, who was 64 at the time, was charged with causing a disturbance and breaching a court order.

Pelkie, then 46, was charged with causing a disturbance and resisting arrest.

Both were subsequently released on undertakings.

Following the incident, the Outlaws Motorcycle Club publicly criticized the police response, maintaining that its members had been unfairly singled out and prevented from honouring military veterans.

Tactical Officers Describe Confrontation

Several members of the Sarnia Police Service have testified about what happened during the ceremony.

Among them were emergency response team officers Jamie Moore and Blair Nield, who had been assigned to provide security at the event.

Moore testified that he noticed Shura wearing an Outlaws motorcycle club vest.

According to Moore, Shura looked toward him and asked whether there was going to be a problem.

The officer said he chose not to respond.

Moore also observed several other people wearing Outlaws leather vests, although he could not determine whether they were fully patched members.

Another unidentified individual reportedly wore clothing associated with the Filthy 15 Motorcycle Club, which Moore described as an affiliated or support organization.

Later, Moore said he received instructions from Deputy Chief Michael Van Sickle to remove the Outlaws members from the wreath-laying line following a request from Legion officials.

Moore approached the group alongside Constable Steven Farlow and Sgt. Dave Ferrera.

According to his testimony, Ferrera calmly informed Shura and another individual that they were not welcome in the procession.

When the men refused to move, Moore physically escorted one unidentified individual away from the lineup.

Officer Says Shura Refused Repeated Requests to Leave

Nield also testified about his attempts to resolve the confrontation.

He told the court that he heard raised voices and swearing as he approached the group.

Nield identified Shura as the source of the disturbance.

Having dealt with Shura previously, the officer believed he might be able to calm the situation through conversation.

However, Nield testified that Shura repeatedly refused requests to leave the wreath-laying line.

According to the officer, Shura insisted he had a right to attend the public Remembrance Day ceremony.

After the confrontation continued, Ferrera informed Shura that he was under arrest for causing a disturbance.

Several officers then moved Shura toward a grassy area to complete the arrest.

Dispute Over Police Contact With Shura’s Wife

The court also heard conflicting accounts of the interaction between police and Pelkie during her husband’s arrest.

Moore testified that Pelkie became agitated and moved extremely close to officers as they attempted to take Shura into custody.

He described her proximity as interference with the arrest.

The officer maintained that the fact Pelkie was recording the incident on her cellphone was not the reason he intervened.

Moore said he attempted to move her away with a light push.

Pelkie subsequently fell to the ground.

According to Moore, he did not intend to knock her down and believed she may have lost her balance.

Pelkie offered a significantly different description of the encounter.

During her testimony, she disputed the suggestion that the contact was minor, telling the court that the force caused her to go flying.

Defence Questions Restrictions at Public Ceremony

Defence lawyer Brenda Sandulak challenged aspects of the officers’ accounts during cross-examination.

A central issue raised by the defence was whether members of the public were permitted to participate in the ceremony and whether restrictions had been clearly communicated.

Sandulak questioned the officers about the public nature of the Remembrance Day service, even though the event was organized by the Royal Canadian Legion.

She also asked whether signs had been posted explaining that wreaths required advance registration or prohibiting motorcycle club colours.

The defence referred to video footage from the ceremony in which a speaker could reportedly be heard inviting anyone else who wished to lay a wreath to come forward.

That announcement became relevant to questions about whether Shura and the others reasonably believed they were permitted to join the procession.

Several recordings of the confrontation, including videos that circulated widely on social media following the arrests, have been played during the trial.

Pelkie Says Group Intended to Honour Veterans

Pelkie, now 48, testified that the decision to attend the Remembrance Day ceremony had been discussed well before the event.

She said she and her husband began planning to attend approximately one week beforehand.

A few days later, they discussed bringing a memorial wreath.

Pelkie testified that she attempted to contact the local Legion branch on a Saturday but was unable to reach anyone.

She then decided to purchase materials and prepare a wreath herself.

During a visit to Michaels, she found a black, sparkling wreath in a discounted merchandise section.

Pelkie explained that the group wanted to recognize military veterans who had connections to the Outlaws Motorcycle Club.

She said several of her husband’s friends had served in wars and suffered injuries, and that they had compiled a list of Outlaws members who were veterans.

Club Members Allegedly Told to Remain Respectful

According to Pelkie, the group gathered at the Outlaws clubhouse on the morning of November 11, 2024, before heading to Veterans Park.

She testified that Shura specifically instructed those attending to behave respectfully.

Members were allegedly told not to act aggressively, draw unnecessary attention or create a disturbance.

Pelkie also said the group made a deliberate decision to travel in cars rather than on motorcycles as a sign of respect for the ceremony.

Although members wore their motorcycle club vests, she maintained that their intention was to honour veterans, not disrupt the proceedings.

Upon arriving near the cenotaph, Pelkie said an individual she described as an army representative questioned whether their wreath had been registered.

When the group acknowledged that it had not, they were reportedly directed to stand behind registered participants in the wreath-laying line.

Pelkie told the court that she believed the group had been permitted to participate after following those instructions.

Witness Describes Feeling Unfairly Targeted

Pelkie testified that armed police officers watched the group for several minutes before instructing them to leave the procession.

She said the experience was upsetting and believed her husband had been unfairly excluded from an event open to the public.

Her account differed from the police testimony concerning the group’s conduct and the events leading up to the arrests.

During cross-examination, assistant Crown attorney Meaghan Jones questioned Pelkie about whether she had contributed to the disturbance.

The prosecutor raised allegations that Pelkie had shouted about constitutional rights, raised her voice and behaved confrontationally toward police.

Pelkie’s evidence and the officers’ testimony are among the accounts the court must consider in determining what occurred.

Trial Continues at Sarnia Courthouse

The proceedings are being prosecuted by assistant Crown attorney Meaghan Jones, while defence lawyer Brenda Sandulak represents Shura and Pelkie.

Justice Krista Lynn Leszczynski is hearing the case without a jury.

With police officers, Pelkie and video evidence already presented, the trial remains focused on the circumstances that led to the confrontation and whether the accused committed the offences alleged.

The case is scheduled to resume in November.

Neither Shura nor Pelkie has been found guilty of the charges arising from the Remembrance Day incident, and both remain presumed innocent unless proven guilty in court.

Pass it along / WTN

SHARE THIS STORY

Found something worth sharing? Spread the news.

X / Twitter Reddit

SHARE CLICKS Facebook1 X1 Reddit0 Link0 Total2