A member of the Hells Angels motorcycle club is suing the city of Livermore for $1 million, saying police falsely accused him of carrying a gun in the saddlebags of his chopper after another biker got into a dust-up with an off-duty air marshal.
Joel Silva said police also caused him to be wrongfully charged in federal court with a weapons violation.
The city of Livermore has not responded to the suit, which was filed Friday in U.S. District Court in San Francisco.
The case stems from an incident Sept. 5, 2008, when Silva was leading a pack of 11 fellow Hells Angels members east on Interstate 580 in Livermore. The group stopped at a Union 76 gas station, where an off-duty air marshal who was riding a motorcycle accused another Hells Angel of having rammed him off the freeway moments earlier. The air marshal had just finished his shift at San Francisco International Airport.
The air marshal called 911, and Livermore officers arrived and detained all the Hells Angels, who by now had surrounded the man and looked angry, Livermore police said.
Silva said officers handcuffed him, patted him down and then released him. But after police arrested two other Hells Angels for having guns, officers did an “about-face†and again detained and handcuffed Silva, before once again releasing him, the suit said.
That wasn’t the end of it, however. Officers surrounded Silva again and pointed their guns at him, demanding to search his motorcycle, which they hadn’t done yet, the suit said. Silva refused, but officers searched the bike anyway and falsely stated that they had found a .38-caliber handgun in his saddlebag, his suit said.
Silva was arrested on suspicion of being an ex-felon with a gun. No charges were filed, but Silva was indicted by a federal grand jury on a weapons violation based on the allegedly false report by Livermore police, the suit says.
U.S. District Judge Phyllis Hamilton later granted Silva’s motion to suppress evidence on the grounds that his motorcycle had been illegally searched.
“It sounds to me like it’s a fishing expedition of some sort,†Hamilton told WS Wilson Leung, a federal prosecutor who argued the government’s case.
Prosecutors said the Livermore officers had acted properly in dealing with a large contingent of angry Hells Angels.
Leung noted that the incident occurred just three days after Mark “Papa†Guardado, the leader of the San Francisco Hells Angels chapter, had been shot dead, allegedly by a member of a rival biker club.
As a result of the shooting, he said, police were wary of further violence involving bikers.
http://blog.sfgate.com/crime/2011/11/08/hells-angel-sues-livermore/